Preston County Circuit Judge Larry
Miller, Berkeley County Circuit Judge Christopher Wilkes and Pleasants County
Circuit Judge Tim Sweeney issued the 44-page order on Tuesday afternoon after
hearing testimony over parts of two days in September.
The order will be suspended for 30
days to give Plants time to appeal.
“Clearly, there is no winner in a
difficult matter such as this,” said Kanawha County Commission president Kent
Carper in a statement soon after the order was issued.
The Kanawha County Commission had
filed a petition earlier this year to have Plants removed from office. At that
time, the argument was he could not properly do his job while facing his own
charges of domestic battery and violating a protective order.
A special prosecutor had been
appointed to handle the domestic cases Plants could not because of possible
conflicts.
“I strongly believe that filing
this petition was the right thing to do for the taxpayers of Kanawha County ,”
said Kanawha County Commissioner Dave Hardy who raised questions about the
costs of that special prosecutor.
The Kanawha County Commission was
scheduled to meet at 9 a.m. Wednesday to talk about the county’s next steps.